Key takeaways
- Amazon offers instant reach: Ideal for sellers seeking quick access to a vast global audience and hassle-free fulfillment via FBA.
- Shopify empowers brand control: Perfect for businesses focused on building a unique brand, owning customer relationships, and customizing their store.
- Choose based on goals: Amazon suits volume-driven sellers, while Shopify fits long-term brand builders seeking independence and flexibility.
In the ever-expanding digital marketplace, two giants stand out: Amazon and Shopify. Both platforms have revolutionized the way we think about retail, but they cater to different types of sellers and business models. If you're pondering where to set up your online store, understanding the key differences between Shopify vs Amazon is crucial. This comprehensive comparison will help you decide which ecommerce platform is the best fit for your business needs.
Understanding the basics
Amazon is a colossal online marketplace that connects sellers with a global customer base. It's known for its vast product range, customer trust, and sophisticated logistics network. Sellers can list products directly on Amazon’s platform, benefitting from its enormous traffic and established reputation.
Shopify, on the other hand, provides a platform for building your own independent online store. It's a comprehensive ecommerce solution that gives sellers complete control over their shop's design, functionality, and customer experience. Selling on Shopify is ideal for brand-building and creating a unique online presence.
Amazon: the marketplace giant
Pros:
Massive customer base: Amazon has a vast, global audience. This provides unparalleled exposure for your products.
Fulfillment by Amazon (FBA): The Amazon FBA service handles storage, packing, and shipping for sellers, making logistics much easier.
Built-in trust: Consumers trust Amazon, which can lead to higher conversion rates.
Prime eligibility: Products fulfilled by Amazon are eligible for Prime, which can significantly boost sales due to customer preferences for fast shipping.
Cons:
High competition: The Amazon marketplace is highly competitive. Standing out can be challenging, especially for new sellers.
Fees: Amazon charges a variety of fees, including listing fees, fulfillment fees, and referral fees, which can eat into profit margins.
Limited branding: Customizing your product listings is limited. There's little scope for brand-building within Amazon's platform.
Strict policies: Amazon has stringent policies and guidelines that sellers must adhere to, and failure to comply can result in account suspension.
Shopify: The ecommerce innovator
Pros:
Complete brand control: Selling on Shopify gives you the freedom to build and customize your online store to reflect your brand identity.
App integrations: The Shopify App Store offers numerous plugins for additional functionalities, from SEO tools to advanced analytics to VAT compliance.
Direct customer relationships: With Shopify, you have direct interaction with your customers, which is great for building loyalty and repeat business.
No listing fees: Unlike Amazon, Shopify doesn’t charge per-item listing fees. You pay a monthly subscription, and transaction fees.
Cons:
Customer acquisition: You are responsible for driving traffic to your store, which can be a significant challenge, especially for new brands.
Logistics management: Unlike Amazon FBA, you are responsible for managing storage, packing, and shipping, unless you partner with a third-party logistics provider.
Learning curve: Building and managing a Shopify store requires more technical know-how than listing products on Amazon.
SEO and marketing efforts: You’ll need to invest in SEO and marketing to make your ecommerce store visible in the crowded online space.
Financial considerations
Amazon costs:
Referral fees: Typically range from 6% to 45% of each sale, depending on the category.
Fulfillment fees: Vary based on product size and weight.
Monthly subscription: Professional seller account costs $39.99 per month.
Shopify costs:
Subscription fees: Plans range from $29 to $299 per month.
Transaction fees: These vary based on your plan and the payment gateway used.
Additional costs: Apps and themes may incur additional costs.
Which ecommerce platform is best for you?
If you are a small business or start-up:
Shopify might be a better choice if you want to build a brand and have a unique online presence. The initial setup and marketing efforts require more work, but the long-term benefits of brand loyalty and customer relationships are substantial.
If you are looking to expand reach quickly:
Amazon is your go-to for immediate access to a vast customer base. It's ideal for sellers who want to focus more on the product and less on the intricacies of ecommerce website management.
If you value brand identity and customer relationships:
Choose Shopify. It's more work, but it gives you the freedom to build a loyal customer base and a distinctive brand identity.
If you want a hassle-free logistics solution:
Amazon’s FBA service takes the headache out of logistics, making it a great option for those who prefer to focus on other aspects of their business.
Conclusion
Amazon and Shopify cater to different seller needs and objectives. Amazon offers a vast audience and streamlined logistics at the cost of higher competition and lower brand control. Shopify, on the other hand, offers greater customization and brand control but requires more effort in customer acquisition and logistics management.
Your choice of digital marketplace depends on what aspects of ecommerce are most important for your business model and long-term goals. Both ecommerce platforms have the potential to be incredibly lucrative; it's just a matter of finding the right fit for your business.
Do you need help with your VAT compliance? Book a free call with one of our VAT experts to find bespoke solutions for your business, optimize your VAT costs, and reach millions of new potential customers.
Frequently asked questions
What’s the main difference between selling on Shopify and Amazon?
Shopify lets you build your own branded online store, giving you full control over design, pricing, and customer relationships. Amazon is a global marketplace where you list products among competitors and benefit from its massive customer base and logistics network.
Which platform is better for new sellers?
If you want quick access to a large audience and minimal setup, Amazon is ideal. If your goal is to build a brand and long-term customer loyalty, Shopify offers more control and growth potential.
How do costs compare between Shopify and Amazon?
Amazon charges referral and fulfillment fees plus a monthly subscription, while Shopify has tiered subscription plans and small transaction fees. Shopify’s costs are more predictable, but Amazon can drive faster sales volume.
Can I use both platforms at once?
Yes. Many sellers use Amazon for reach and Shopify for brand-building. Integrating both can diversify sales and reduce dependence on a single platform.
Which platform handles shipping and logistics better?
Amazon’s Fulfillment by Amazon (FBA) manages storage, packing, and delivery for you. Shopify sellers must handle or outsource logistics—but this allows for greater flexibility and branding in the shipping experience.
