We’ve helped 20,000+ companies grow
Global coverage. Local expertise.
badge
Future-ready compliance for all.
←  Blog
7
min read

What the Supreme Court’s Ruling on Sales Tax Means to Small Businesses

Read our overview of the Supreme Court's South Dakota v. Wayfair decision and what it means for your small business.
USA
Sales Tax
Nexus
Author
Jenny Longmuir
Last updated
2026-10-09
What the Supreme Court’s Ruling on Sales Tax Means to Small Businesses
Table of content

Key takeaways

  1. The Wayfair ruling replaced Quill’s physical presence rule: Businesses must now collect and remit sales tax in states where they exceed $100,000 in sales or 200 transactions, even without a physical presence.
  2. States gained broader taxing authority: The decision opened the door for all states to enforce economic nexus laws, increasing compliance obligations for online sellers.‍
  3. Small businesses face new compliance challenges: While large retailers are mostly prepared, smaller e-commerce businesses may need accounting support and automation tools like LumaTax to stay compliant.

In short: In South Dakota v. Wayfair, the Supreme Court overturned the 1992 Quill ruling and its physical-presence rule for sales tax. States can now require online sellers to collect sales tax based on sales into the state. South Dakota's law set a threshold of $100,000 in sales or 200 transactions a year.

Update: From July 1, 2023, South Dakota dropped the 200-transaction test, so only the $100,000 sales threshold now applies.

Going into the Supreme Court's hearing of the South Dakota v. Wayfair case, argued in April, one thing was certain: something had to give. States were struggling to expand their sales-tax reach while bumping up against an old ruling. The legal environment was getting more complicated, and more clarity had been needed for some time.

Compliance with use-tax laws is low, and online retail sales had grown to over $453 billion a year. So states believe they're missing out on billions of dollars in uncollected tax money.

Now the decision has been made to overturn the 1992 Quill Corp. v. North Dakota ruling. This allows South Dakota to throw out the physical-presence test. Instead, it can use a threshold rule for online businesses that sell to residents of the state.

Under this rule, online sellers have legal nexus and must collect sales tax in South Dakota in two cases. The first is if they gross more than $100,000 in sales of tangible personal property to South Dakota residents in a given year. The second is if they make more than 200 such separate transactions.

And just like that, with Quill no longer restricting them, other states are free to expand their definition of nexus beyond physical presence as well.

Below, we'll unpack what this means to you as a business owner.

__wf_reserved_inherit
SCOTUS's ruling may affect the largest online retailers less than small businesses.

‍
Is This Good News or Bad News?

It's too soon to tell whether the Wayfair ruling is good or bad news, because we don't know exactly what individual states will do. If the decision leads states to adopt more uniform sales tax rules, that would be good. But if it lets states overreach and make online business needlessly complex, it could be bad.

Some people oppose the decision to overrule Quill and uphold South Dakota's law. They believe it will overburden small businesses, because states can now require sales-tax collection on online sales without the physical-presence restriction. They expect more extreme sales-tax laws than South Dakota's as a result.

They also fear that the cost of doing business online will become too high for all but the largest retailers.

Others agree with the decision. They believe large online retailers were in effect enabling tax evasion by shoppers. In some cases, these retailers even advertised “you don’t have to pay sales tax” as a benefit of shopping with them. Supporters say this added to state budget deficits. It also gave online retailers an unfair edge over retailers with a physical presence in a given state.

Another concern was that some large businesses had an incentive to avoid a physical presence in certain states. This could harm the economies there. Some also feared that states would keep adding workarounds to the physical-presence rule. Over time, the sales tax rules for online sellers could become impossible for small businesses to follow.

Quill's incentive for businesses
Quill's incentive for businesses to avoid a physical presence in certain states was a concern to the Court.

‍
The fact is that 31 states already have laws in effect that tax internet sales by out-of-state sellers. Many of those laws are more complex and roundabout than the South Dakota law that was just upheld. States have already put in place several workarounds to the physical-presence rule upheld by Quill, including:

  • Expansion of nexus to include “click-through” and affiliate relationships.
  • Expansion of nexus by invoking “economic nexus.”
  • Threshold laws – like South Dakota's.
  • “Notice and reporting laws,” such as the one passed by Colorado.
  • Expansion of nexus by creating “cookie nexus” as Massachusetts has tried to do.

The court has now overruled Quill, which in effect ends the physical-presence requirement for online sales-tax collection. This puts pressure on Congress to clearly define nexus. The definition needs to fit today's economy but still protect small businesses. Leaving the door open to even more complex and varied rules for online businesses seems out of the question.

Curious how we got here? Keep reading...

What Events Led Up to This Decision?

The decision goes back to 1992, when the Supreme Court ruled in Quill v. North Dakota. It said states could not legally require out-of-state sellers with no physical presence there to register and collect sales tax. These included the mail order catalogs of the day. Instead, consumers would still have to pay use tax to their home states where sales tax was not charged.

Online sales volume ramped up, and brick-and-mortar retail sales declined. So states searched for ways to collect the tax they were legally due on sales made by large online retailers. Congress had the power to pass federal laws on online retailers' duties to states, but it did not.

decline in brick-and-mortar retail sales.
State budgets have suffered from the decline in brick-and-mortar retail sales.

‍
South Dakota passed an economic nexus law that got around the physical presence requirement. Wayfair and other large retailers refused to comply and challenged the law as unconstitutional. South Dakota sued those retailers (Wayfair, Newegg, and Overstock.com). After losing in the lower court, it appealed to the Supreme Court.

As part of its case, South Dakota agreed in advance not to collect the tax retroactively from retail businesses. It also signed on to the Streamlined Sales and Use Tax Agreement, which seeks to cut the cost and admin burden on retailers.

Many legal briefs were filed with the Supreme Court on both sides of the case. Meanwhile, Congress failed to act on several proposed bills. These were meant to clarify and define the states' taxing powers over internet sales while everyone waited for the SCOTUS decision.

In its ruling, the Court decided in favor of South Dakota. It said the South Dakota law does not burden interstate commerce and can stand as is, with its limits on the burden it can place on businesses. The Court ruled that the Quill decision to define nexus by physical presence was no longer relevant in today's economy.

Why Now?

The Supreme Court acted now because the huge volume of daily sales across state lines, and the billions of dollars at stake, finally created a tipping point.

SCOTUS has explained its reasons for overruling Quill in this way:

  • The physical presence rule no longer reflects economic reality, as a business doesn't need a physical presence to do massive business within a state.
  • Quill creates incentives for businesses to avoid setting up distribution channels or employment centers in certain states just to avoid the tax. Keeping Quill in place, “deprives states of vast revenues from major businesses.”
  • South Dakota's law affords small businesses a reasonable degree of protection.

The Court noted that some issues that could harm small businesses were not before it to decide at this time. These include new laws that apply retroactively (which South Dakota's will not), a lack of uniformity from one place to the next, and other states not setting thresholds. That reality may spur Congress to finally act.

What Does the Ruling Mean for Online Retail as a Whole?

For online retail as a whole, the ruling's impact is likely to be limited. Large online retailers such as Amazon gained an advantage from Quill when they first started out, but many now collect sales tax on most sales. Some, like Wayfair, have said publicly that the decision won't have a drastic impact on their current business. Still, stocks in companies such as Amazon and Overstock.com took a hit as investors reacted to the decision.

On the whole, technology will help reduce the impact of the SCOTUS decision across the industry. This is the same technology that allowed explosive growth in ecommerce and spurred the states to act. Software like LumaTax now lets even smaller companies easily file and pay sales tax to the right state. Online shopping carts and merchant services like Square can also be set up to collect the tax automatically.

It's a safe bet that states will now act to collect tax on online sales in one way or another. But that seems unlikely to hurt or slow the growth of those sales in a noticeable way. The momentum behind that growth at this point is simply too great.

What Does the Ruling Mean for Small Businesses?

For small businesses, the ruling's main effect so far depends on what states do next. Much of the reaction in the small business community is based more on guesses about what states might do than on any immediate effects.

Say you make sales in South Dakota totaling more than 200 transactions or over $100,000 in a year. Then you'll need to register to collect sales tax with the state's Department of Revenue now. You'll also need to know the correct rate.

The cost of selling online across state lines will definitely go up for some. But we still don't know what thresholds other states will set before sales-tax rules kick in. So it's not yet a given that every small business will be affected. If you don't sell online or ship products out of state, it's likely that nothing will change for you.

Remember that it's still unclear what action, if any, Congress will take to limit the reach of the states. There's no reason for small ecomm businesses to panic yet. But it is a great time to consult an accountant who will track all the changes to the laws.

Meanwhile, much of the technology needed to automate sales-tax collection, reporting, and payment is already available. It's also more affordable now than it's ever been.

What Do You Need to Do Now?

Stay tuned: States are in the process of reacting to the SCOTUS ruling. Keep in mind those 31 states that already have rules that may affect you. Watch for new tax rules in states where you haven't had to collect so far. As we mentioned before, look out for any action Congress takes that could affect your business in the future.

A few steps to consider as the states react to the decision:

  • Check in with your accountant now, or consider hiring one soon, so you stay in the loop on any changes to the law.
  • If you don't already use it, start looking at tax software options that will keep your business compliant automatically.
  • Be ready to update your shopping carts and point-of-sale systems to reflect new tax rates. Square users can see our guide to setting up sales tax here.
  • Use our state-by-state tax guides to check the rules already in place in the states where you currently make sales. Follow the links there to check for updates.

How Taxually handles this

Taxually’s LumaTax runs a nexus analysis on your sales, helps you register in the states where you must collect, and prepares and files multi-state sales tax returns, including Canadian GST/HST. LumaTax is currently available to enterprises and accounting firms. For the full workflow, read how to automate US sales tax filing in every state.

Related guides

Author
Jenny Longmuir
•
Copywriter
Jenny Longmuir is a content writer with experience in tax and fintech. At Taxually, she covers topics such as global tax compliance, digital reporting, and automation, helping businesses stay informed about the evolving regulatory landscape. Her work focuses on making complex financial and compliance information clear and accessible to a broad audience.
FAQ

Frequently asked questions

What was the outcome of the Wayfair case?‍

The Supreme Court overturned the 1992 Quill ruling, eliminating the physical presence rule. Now, states can require online sellers to collect and remit sales tax if they meet certain economic thresholds—such as $100,000 in sales or 200 transactions in a state.

How does this affect online businesses?‍

Online sellers that exceed a state’s economic nexus threshold must register, collect, and remit sales tax, even without a physical location. Small businesses with limited out-of-state sales may remain unaffected, but compliance complexity will increase overall.

What should businesses do to stay compliant?‍

Businesses should review their sales activity by state, monitor evolving state thresholds, and consider using automated tax software like LumaTax to simplify registration, filing, and ongoing compliance across multiple jurisdictions.

Powering Global Compliance.
Discover a smarter way to manage tax across every market.

Simplify your global sales tax -
track, report and pay with ease!

Join 20,000+ businesses worldwide, from startups to global enterprises, to stay compliant, eliminate manual work, and scale with confidence across every market.
Book a 30-minutes demo
Trusted by the world's leading companies
Amazon logoShopify logoRazour group logoBBC logoebay logostripe logostripe logostripe logo
Amazon logoShopify logoRazour group logoBBC logoebay logostripe logostripe logostripe logo
Amazon logoShopify logoRazour group logoBBC logoebay logostripe logostripe logostripe logo

Suggested articles