Key takeaways
- COVID-19 disrupted consumption and sales tax revenue: The pandemic caused historic declines in spending, threatening a major funding source for state and local governments.
- Wayfair expanded enforcement potential: States now rely on economic nexus to tax remote sellers, increasing scrutiny of out-of-state businesses.
- Accountants must prepare clients for audits: With shrinking local revenues, states will intensify enforcement—making proactive nexus reviews and compliance essential.
In short: The COVID-19 shutdown caused a sudden, sharp fall in US consumer spending, which threatens state and local sales tax revenue. With in-state retail shuttered, states are expected to enforce economic nexus laws under South Dakota v. Wayfair more aggressively against remote sellers. As a trusted advisor, you should prepare your clients now.
Never in our lifetimes have we seen a global, government-enforced shutdown of economic activity. Just the thought of it is, frankly, mind-boggling. Governments and central banks normally work to spur economic activity. But this time, we have been asked to curb it.
What will be the effect? How long will the ripples run through our economy? Which industries will be hit hardest? What is the impact on state and local tax revenues and budgets? These questions will be answered over the years. But for many local communities, the most pressing issue is the immediate impact of lost sales on sales tax revenue. For a closer look, see Practice Development: Sales Tax Economic Nexus Under Wayfair.
What drives the US economy?
The United States economy was booming in 2019, with GDP hitting $21.4 trillion[1]. Personal consumption, the driver of the US economy, made up $14.56 trillion[2] or roughly 70% of the economy. Personal consumption was $4.5 trillion in goods and $10 trillion in services[3].
Personal consumption is driven mainly by individual income. The higher the income, the greater the consumption. Personal income rose to $18.6 trillion in 2019, with average individual income rising to $58,379.45 in the US[4]. Consumer spending also depends on what people expect for inflation, unemployment and income.
This is a simplified view. But it is a big reason why the US economy has performed so well in recent years. As of the beginning of 2020, the U.S. economy had grown without a break since 2009. The unemployment rate was near a 50-year low and the stock market was pushing towards a record high. All these factors led US consumers to spend more.

What was the economic impact of COVID-19?
Then came the COVID-19 pandemic. The sudden, intense decline of the US economy that followed has no parallel in history. Based on the early numbers, the impact is staggering. Unemployment claims rose by 22 million in April, raising the unemployment rate to 14.7% from 4.4%. US consumer spending plunged 7.5% in March, according to the Commerce Department. That was the sharpest monthly drop since 1959.
Personal income fell by 2%, with wages and salaries falling by 3.1% due to the mass layoffs. The Government reported that GDP shrank at an annual rate of 4.8% for the first quarter[5]. Analysts are predicting the GDP will shrink by 40% in the current April-June quarter[6].
“We are looking at something quite grave,” said economist Janet L. Yellen, the former Federal Reserve chair. “If businesses suffer such serious losses and are forced to fire workers and have their firms go into bankruptcy,” she warned. “It may not be easy to pull out of that.”
Why is Sales Tax Important?
Sales tax gives state and local governments valuable resources to serve their local communities. Sales taxes make up a large part of their overall budgets. In particular, sales taxes fund schools, roads, fire and police, and public transportation. Approximately $437 billion of sales tax was collected in 2019[7]. That was about 35% of “own-source” state general revenue[8].
Forty-five states and the District of Columbia impose a general sales tax on goods and services (with some exemptions). In addition, thirty-seven of these states impose a local sales tax at the County, City, and/or Municipality/Agency level. Sales taxes fall into two categories: general sales tax and selective sales tax. General sales tax comes from the sales of most goods and certain services. Selective sales taxes come from the sale of motor fuels, alcohol and tobacco.
How does this affect state revenues?
In past recessions, sales tax has been the most stable source of tax revenue for state and local governments. That's because spending habits stay steadier than income levels. Government assistance, unemployment benefits, personal savings or other non-taxable income often support spending. This is why sales tax revenues stay fairly stable during a downturn.
Today, with less physical retail, states are ready to aggressively enforce economic nexus laws. Most in-state retail businesses are shuttered. So audit departments will shift from auditing local retailers to auditing out-of-state retailers who do business in their state[9]. Read more in our guide: Practice Development: Voluntary Disclosure Agreements Post-Wayfair.
Where does Wayfair stand, two years later?
Governments are armed with fresh law. South Dakota vs Wayfair[10] is the landmark Supreme Court decision issued on June 21, 2018. It ruled that “economic nexus”, with some limitations, is enough for a state to enforce its tax rules on out-of-state, or remote, sellers.
South Dakota's threshold model sets a minimum of $100K in gross sales or 200 transactions. Once a business passes it, economic nexus is triggered. The business must then collect and remit sales tax. You can also read State and Local Tax (SALT): What's New and What's Next.
What about remote and online sales after Wayfair?
For state and local governments, there may be a silver lining to the loss of instate sales tax revenues from COVID-19. Online spending is growing at an incredible rate. Even so, it still makes up only roughly 11.0% of total retail sales, according to Commerce Department retail data. Consumers spent $599.5 billion online with U.S. merchants in 2019, up 14.4% from $523.64 billion in 2018.
Online transactions through Amazon, Walmart, Target, eBay, Etsy and other marketplace facilitators are a new revenue source, thanks to recent changes in the law. As this trend continues, state governments will have to tap into this commerce as a revenue source.
What enforcement activity should you expect?
It has taken a couple of years for states to pass “Wayfair” laws and put the rules in place. In this past year, most states have relied on voluntary enforcement. But with over-the-counter sales falling, states will have to review their enforcement under Wayfair. It is reasonable to expect state enforcement to get more aggressive as the second half of the year unfolds.
Before COVID-19, audit departments spent a lot of time auditing local retailers. Now they will shift their focus to out-of-state retailers that have been doing business in their state. This makes logical sense. It also makes fiscal sense for state and local agencies, since most of their instate retail businesses have been shuttered.
How can you prepare your clients?
Now, more than ever, the CPA community will be called on to advise their clients. After Wayfair, the AICPA shared some thoughts on how firms must respond to the decision. It covers how to notify clients to avoid potential professional liability. The AICPA outlines a 7-step plan for reducing this risk to the practice.
Many clients are fighting to survive, while others are thriving with an established online presence. Traditional brick-and-mortar companies will need to expand quickly through e-commerce if they want to survive. Now is the time to prepare yourself and your clients for the enforcement that will follow.
State and local audit departments are unlikely to enforce aggressively while the COVID-19 pandemic is still widespread. More likely, they will spend the next six months working out how best to extend enforcement to remote sellers.
This will happen eventually, but the COVID-19 economic losses will speed up the timeline. In-state retailers' sales can realistically be expected to shrink by as much as 60%. So governments have no choice but to look to the remote sellers doing business in their state.
The impact of COVID-19 on state revenue sources is clear. As the trusted advisor, you must be prepared for upcoming enforcement actions. To properly protect your taxpayer client and minimize their overall risk, you need a thorough understanding of several things. These include economic nexus rules, lookback periods, transaction summations and counts, and registration timelines. They also include marketplace facilitator implications and calculated exposure amounts.
Using the LumaTax solution, you never have to worry about tracking all of these varying parameters to deliver this advisory service efficiently and effectively.
References:
- US Bureau of Economic Analysis, Table 5: Value Added by Industry Group,
- BEA: GDP by industry
- Ibid, Table 5
- Ibid, Table 5
- Statista: US personal income
- BEA: GDP, first quarter 2020 (advance estimate)
- CNBC: US personal income, March 2020
- US Census Bureau, Quarterly Summary of State and Local Tax Revenue
- Own source revenue excludes intergovernmental transfers
- Bloomberg Tax: Businesses urged to prepare for post-coronavirus compliance surge
- US Supreme Court: South Dakota v. Wayfair opinion (PDF)
How Taxually handles this
Taxually’s LumaTax runs a nexus analysis on your sales, helps you register in the states where you must collect, and prepares and files multi-state sales tax returns, including Canadian GST/HST. LumaTax is currently available to enterprises and accounting firms. For the full workflow, read how to automate US sales tax filing in every state.
Related guides
Frequently asked questions
How did COVID-19 affect state and local tax revenues?
The pandemic caused a historic decline in consumer spending and retail activity, leading to major drops in sales tax revenues — a key funding source for schools, infrastructure, and public services.
Why are states focusing more on remote sellers?
With many physical stores closed, states are turning to economic nexus laws under the Wayfair ruling to ensure out-of-state online sellers collect and remit sales tax on transactions within their borders.
What should accountants and businesses do to prepare?
Businesses should review their nexus exposure, registration timelines, and sales data across states. CPAs can use tools like LumaTax to identify compliance risks and help clients meet new enforcement demands efficiently.

















