Key takeaways
- On February 29 2024, the CJEU ruled that VAT refunds on bad debts in Bulgaria can be claimed without issuing a credit note or notifying the debtor.
- The decision affects refund claims for periods before 2023, broadening access to VAT recovery for suppliers with uncollected debts.
- Prior to the judgment, Bulgarian tax authorities frequently rejected refund claims due to strict procedural requirements.
- The ruling aligns Bulgaria’s VAT practice with EU law, ensuring fairer treatment for suppliers and potential state-compensation claims for past denials.
- Businesses should review historic bad-debt cases to identify possible refund opportunities.
In short: On February 29, 2024, the Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU) ruled on VAT refunds for bad debts in Bulgaria. Suppliers could adjust their tax base and claim VAT back on uncollected debts without issuing a credit note or notifying the debtor. This may reopen refund claims for periods before 2023.
On February 29, the Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU) delivered a landmark judgment on VAT refunds on bad debts in Bulgaria. It could reshape VAT refund practices for periods before 2023. The 2024 CJEU judgment made clear that suppliers could adjust their tax base and claim VAT refunds on uncollected debts. They did not need to issue a credit note or notify the debtor.
What led to the CJEU bad debts judgment?
Getting VAT refunds on "bad" debts used to be hard, both in Bulgaria and the wider EU. Bulgaria’s VAT Act of 2006 was unclear on how to handle VAT on uncollected payments until it was amended in 2023. A landmark CJEU case from 2018 led to that amendment. The VAT Act now includes a way to get VAT refunds when the payment for a supply is not collected.
Before this, Bulgarian tax authorities and courts often rejected VAT refund claims on procedural grounds, such as a missing credit note. This created barriers for suppliers.
What exactly did the CJEU rule?
The case is C-314/22, Consortium Remi Group, referred by Bulgaria's Supreme Administrative Court. The Court interpreted Article 90 of the EU VAT Directive and made three main points:
- Limitation periods: a member state may set a time limit for bad-debt VAT refunds. But the period can only start once the business could claim the reduction without a lack of diligence.
- Formal conditions: without specific national rules, the tax authority cannot require the supplier to first correct the invoice and notify the debtor. This applies where doing so in time was impossible for reasons beyond the supplier's control.
- Interest: a right to reduce the taxable amount gives a right to a VAT refund with late-payment interest. Without national rules, interest runs from the VAT return in which the business claims the reduction.
What happened in the Consortium Remi Group case?
A Bulgarian construction company had paid VAT on invoices that its customers never paid. When it asked for the VAT back years later, the tax authority refused the claim as time-barred.
- The company issued the invoices to five customers between 2006 and 2012. The unpaid VAT came to BGN 618,171.16.
- In February 2020, the company applied to offset the VAT, plus late-payment interest. The authority rejected the application under the Bulgarian limitation rules.
- The CJEU ruled only on supplies from 2007 onwards. It had no jurisdiction over the 2006 supplies, made before Bulgaria joined the EU.
The Court noted that insolvency proceedings can take a long time to show that a debt cannot be recovered. That is why the limitation period cannot start before a diligent business could claim the reduction.
Can EU countries refuse VAT relief on unpaid invoices?
Only within limits. Article 90(1) of the EU VAT Directive says the taxable amount must be reduced in the case of total or partial non-payment. Member states set the conditions.
Article 90(2) lets member states derogate from this rule for non-payment. Bulgaria had no clear procedure until 2023.
What does the 2024 CJEU judgment mean for businesses?
The 2024 CJEU judgment widens the scope for VAT refund claims, because a credit note is no longer strictly required. This opens up refund chances for businesses that were refused on these grounds before. The ruling also affects ongoing tax disputes and unclaimed VAT refunds.
It could also lead to claims for state compensation. Businesses harmed by past national decisions that set strict conditions for VAT refunds, contrary to EU law, may be able to claim.
What should suppliers do now?
- List unpaid invoices where you paid output VAT but never received payment.
- Check which refund claims were rejected because no credit note was issued or the debtor was not notified.
- Work out when you could first have claimed the reduction, as this affects the limitation period.
- Include late-payment interest in any refund claim.
The ruling interprets EU law, so its principles matter beyond Bulgaria. For Bulgarian VAT rules, see our Bulgaria VAT guide.
How Taxually handles this
Taxually’s CrossTax handles VAT registration, VAT, OSS and IOSS returns and fiscal representation in the countries you sell into, and checks your sales data against 250+ validation rules before each filing. OneTax then pays every tax authority with one bulk payment in your chosen currency.
Related guides
Frequently asked questions
What was the CJEU ruling about?
It clarified that suppliers can adjust their VAT base and claim refunds for uncollected debts without needing to issue a credit note or notify the debtor.
Why is this significant for Bulgaria?
It overturns restrictive national practices that previously blocked VAT refunds on procedural grounds.
Does the judgment apply retroactively?
Yes, it may affect claims for VAT periods prior to 2023, subject to statutory limitation periods.
What does this mean for ongoing tax disputes?
Pending or previously denied refund cases may now have grounds for reconsideration or appeal.
Can businesses seek compensation?
Potentially yes—if prior rejections caused financial loss due to conditions found contrary to EU law.
What should companies do next?
Review past bad-debt VAT filings, consult legal counsel, and consider reopening claims under the updated interpretation.
How does this align with EU principles?
It reinforces the EU principle of VAT neutrality and ensures uniform application of refund rights across Member States.
Is interest due on bad-debt VAT refunds?
Yes. The CJEU held that a bad-debt VAT refund carries late-payment interest. Without national rules, interest runs from the VAT return in which the business claims the reduction.
What is the case number of the CJEU bad debts judgment?
It is Case C-314/22, Consortium Remi Group, decided on 29 February 2024. It was referred by Bulgaria's Supreme Administrative Court.
Does EU law require VAT relief on unpaid invoices?
Article 90 of the EU VAT Directive requires the taxable amount to be reduced when an invoice is not paid, under conditions set by each member state. Member states may derogate from this rule for non-payment.

















